Tuesday, 19 September 2017

WE AE NOT ALONE!



WE ARE NOT ALONE!
Democracy is not just for humans
How animals vote to make group decisions
September 18, 2017 2.20pm BST

Author

Jan Hoole Lecturer in Biology, Keele University
Today we opt for ballot boxes but humans have used numerous ways of voting to have their say throughout history. However, we’re not the only ones living (or seeking to live) in a democratic society: a new study has suggested that African wild dogs vote to make group decisions.
A new study has found that these dogs sneeze to decide when to stop resting and start hunting. Researchers found that the rates of sneezing during greeting rallies – which happen after, or sometimes during, a rest period – affect the likelihood of the pack departing to hunt, rather than going back to sleep.
If dominant individuals start the rally it is much more likely to result in a hunt, and only two or three sneezes are required to get the pack started. But if a subordinate individual wishes to start a hunt, they have to sneeze a lot more – around ten times – to get the pack to move off.
The researchers think that this sneezing is the pack members voting on when to start a hunt, since it is often the lower ranking (and therefore the hungriest) dogs who start the rallies.
Communal decisions are essential for social living, and in animals it is rare to find a social system where one individual coerces the rest of the group into performing a particular action. But since animals cannot produce the kind of pre-election propaganda so beloved of human politicians, social groups must have different ways of suggesting and gaining consensus for activities.

1. Baboons: take it or leave it

When members of a baboon troupe set off to forage, several members may move in different directions. Other baboons in the group must decide which one to follow, and social dominance has no effect on the likelihood that the majority of the group will follow. Moving purposefully seems to be an important factor in getting other individuals to follow – another parallel with human behaviour, since people will follow whoever seems to have the most confidence .

2. Meerkat voice voting

In meerkat mobs, social cohesion is vital for survival, and moving from one patch to another must be done together. A meerkat going it alone will very soon be an ex-meerkat. In order to get the group to head quickly to a new patch, an individual will emit a “moving call”. If three or more meerkats make moving calls within a short period of time, the group will speed up its movement, but two or less individuals calling does not affect the speed. In meerkat mobs three is evidently considered a quorum.

3. Capuchin monkeys “trill”

White faced capuchin monkeys at a site in Costa Rica have been heard using “trill” calls to persuade the group to move off in the direction preferred by the caller. However, the callers were not always successful in getting the group to move, and status within the group did not seem to affect the likelihood of persuading the troupe to move. Although the researchers did not consider the possibility that these calls were a form of voting, there are similarities between their use and the sneezes used by the wild dogs.

4. Honey bee scouts vote among themselves

Honey bees have an advanced social system with individual workers having different tasks. When a nest becomes overcrowded and some of the bees need to move out, scout bees go off to find a suitable site for a new nest. Of course, they all find different sites and some may find more than one location.
When they return to the swarm, the scouts each perform a dance that gives directions to their chosen site. As time goes on some of the scouts stop advertising their site, and a few will switch to advertising another scout’s site. The swarm will only move when all the scouts that are still dancing are advertising the same site. This process can take several days to complete, but it is a bit like buying a house without having seen it on the say-so of a few estate agents.

5. Ants vote with their feet

Rock ants, found in the south of England, choose a new nest site based on the quality of the site, with entrance size and darkness among assessed criteria. They appear to use a simple voting system consisting of leaving the nest site if an individual does not perceive the quality to be high enough. When enough ants have accumulated at a site, it is deemed to be of a suitable quality (or perhaps the best that can be found in the area), and the ants move in. If the quality subsequently deteriorates, individuals drift away to another site until enough of the colony have left the original nest and joined the new site. A simple, but apparently effective system.
Voting by animals is not a subject that has been studied to any great extent, although political systems are common among social animals and are quite well documented, but if wild dog, meerkats and ants are doing it, you can bet your bottom dollar that other species are doing it too. (ends)



* * * * *


AN UNRELATED THOUGHT

"The best way to take control over a people and control them utterly is to take a little of their freedom at a time, to erode rights by a thousand tiny and almost imperceptible reductions. In this way the people will not see those rights and freedoms being removed until past the point at which these changes cannot be reversed" - Adolf Hitler














The article by Jan Hoole is reproduced with permission

Sunday, 20 August 2017

PARLIAMENT IS SEPARATE FROM GOVERNMENT and has little to do with democracy - discuss

Government is a Closed User Group

19 August 2017 – I’ve touched on this subject before today but it seems to me to be time for a review.

Parliament is separate from government. Made up of the House of Commons and the House of Lords, its role is to:
  • look at what the government is doing
  • debate issues and pass new laws 
  •               ●  set taxes  (source: www.gov.uk )
The Prime Minister is head of the UK government and is ultimately responsible for all policy and decisions. The Prime Minister oversees the operation of the Civil Service and government agencies; appoints members of the government; is the principal government figure in the House of Commons. Hence, we have PMQs on Wednesday when Parliament can ask public questions and expect honest answers.

The Civil Service does the practical and administrative work of government. It is co-ordinated and managed by the Prime Minister, in the role of Minister for the Civil Service.

A candidate for election to Parliament must first be nominated by both the local party branch and party headquarters - rather like a popularity contest among vested interests; then, on polling day, must obtain the largest number of votes in the constituency. It doesn’t matter if the total number of votes for other candidates, plus the numbers who didn’t vote, exceeds the number who actually voted for the candidate. We call this ‘first past the post’ voting, or winner takes all.

 Thus, the elected person is first and foremost a representative of The Party, not a representative of the constituents. Now there’s a thought. Surely, this means that a true constituency representative ought to be ‘independent’ (of all parties).


Once elected, the representative can jostle for a position within the party, including that of Leader of the Party. Nominations are decided and voted upon by fellow inmates, i.e. those who have also been elected to Parliament. The process is offered to the party faithful outside parliament only as a last resort.



I apologise if I seem to be teaching Grandma how to suck eggs but I know from experience that many people who vote don’t really understand how the machine works. Please bear with me.

I think all of us understand that The Party with the greatest number of representatives in Parliament gets to form a government and, provided the gap between the winning party and the first losing party is large enough, the first losing party (main Opposition) becomes irrelevant without further wheeling and dealing agreements with other losers. I’m not overlooking that the winning party is also able to wheel and deal.

The Leader of the winning Party becomes the Prime Minister, and thus becomes, inevitably, less and less concerned about and more and more remote from his or her constituency voters. Their job is done (until they are needed again at the next election). Looked at this way we could argue that ALL those in that constituency have become effectively disenfranchised, regardless of how they did or didn’t vote.

The Leader, now the Prime Minister, must select a government, beginning with a Cabinet. The Cabinet (always of the same party) is made up of the senior members of government. Every week during Parliament, members of the Cabinet (Secretaries of State from all departments and some other ministers) meet to discuss the most important issues for the government. ( www.gov.uk ).

So, today we have one Prime Minister, 22 Cabinet Ministers, and 95 other Ministers, all acknowledged party faithful. (My local political party representative is also a Minister of Defence. I asked him why I could never identify him in the House of Commons when I view proceedings on BBC Parliament TV? He told me that he is a member of government. He answers questions – when asked; he doesn’t ask any! Isn’t that revealing?). Ministers may be chosen from the House of Lords as well as from the House of Commons.

This means that +/- 118 constituencies are effectively disenfranchised after they have voted by virtue of the fact that their supposed representative cannot represent them. His or her loyalty is to the Party and now the Government. To be disloyal will cost him/her the job – not the parliamentary seat, but the job, for which extra payment is received – somewhere in the region of an extra £33,000 p.a. - on top of standard MP remuneration (£70,000+ and expenses). Therefore, Ministers are indebted to the Prime Minister and not to their constituents for five years. It just adds emphasis to the saying that ‘a dog cannot serve two masters’ (without intending any disrespect to dogs).

In UK today the governing party is a minority government and holds just 316 seats out of a possible 650, and 118 of those 316 are held by a minister. But it doesn’t end there.

There are 25 ministerial departments; 21 non-ministerial departments, and 300+ agencies and other public bodies mostly run by Civil Servants answerable somewhere down the line to a minister, but nobody votes for Civil Servants.

Oh! I almost forgot. The Parties have Whips, the bully boys who, with threats, maintain order and compliance among would-be rebels in the parliamentary party.

We also have devolved government across the Kingdom; county councils, borough councils, town councils and parish councils, too. All based upon the party system, all determined to maintain the status quo, and none truly concerned about the citizen or the subject who ultimately pays their wages. I tell you, representative democracy (so-called) is no democracy at all and those who hold the reins of authority know it only too well. They just won’t tell you. This doesn't mean that those who strive to be a good constituency MP are bad people. They are not bad people but it is entirely possible that they are unaware of what is happening around them. They simply don't know what they don't know, like the rest of us.

* * * *

Are there alternatives? Of course there are. Always there are.

I’m thinking in terms of trying to separate parliament from government by making it a requirement that an MP who has accepted the role of minister or Secretary of State must surrender his parliamentary seat – and the salary that goes with it - and the constituency then holds a bye-election to replace him/her, preferably without the involvement of any political party. I suggest that it is a laudable objective to find the best person for the job without the handicap of Party labels. This should have the effect of increasing the number of independent constituency representatives, but it will take time. However, I haven’t a clue how to make that happen!

Unless, of course, the electorate of 118 constituencies could be persuaded, one constituency at a time, to insist on the recall of their party representative, and unseat him/her on grounds of dereliction of duty towards the constituency. There should be only several thousand vested interests to overcome in each constituency!

Alternative (2): Just recognise when you are being deceived, deluded and shafted and don’t worry about it.

Alternative (3): Never vote in parliamentary elections. Make the nomination appear less and less relevant as a proportion of the constituency.







* * * *

New subject: "If you criticise Islam, you are labelled an Islamaphobe. If you dare to criticise the state of Israel, some will label you an anti-Semite. If you oppose equal marriage, you are labelled a homophobe. If you oppose unlimited immigration from EU countries, you are called a racist. If you are Germaine Greer and believe post-operative transgender people “can’t be a woman”, not only are you labelled transgenderphobic, and you can only speak on a university campus with massive security around you for fear that you are going to be attacked. How long can these labels - these methods to shut down debate, continue? We live in a world where hysteria takes the place of rational debate." – Andrew Allison


* * * * *




































Friday, 11 August 2017

What do you mean, exactly?




11 August 2017 - I mused as I read a headline in a national newspaper today. It read:
 

'Racist' Asian sex gangs:



MPs demand tougher sentences for



grooming young white girls


The authors of the article were the newspaper’s CRIME correspondent and its deputy POLITICAL editor. An interesting combination, I thought.  Neither would be responsible for the headline, of course. Headlines are a whole different speciality.

My first thought was to consider the difference between ‘justice’ and ‘vengeance’ and I sought definitions on the website: www.differencebetween.com – inevitably American.


Vengeance vs Justice



“Vengeance and justice are two concepts with a clear difference between them, even though most people tend to confuse these two when wronged. It is quite normal to feel betrayed, angry and hurt, and even vengeful after being wronged by another. Depending on the gravity of the situation, the need to seek revenge or justice can also vary. However, trying to resolve the situation through justice is always a better method rather than the use of vengeance. Through this article, let us examine the differences between these two emotions that people feel.”

Vengeance

It explained further: “The key characteristic in vengeance is that the individual takes the law into his hands, rather than operating within a system. It is not the actual laws that govern his thoughts and actions, but his anger and bottled up emotions. This is the danger of vengeance. The sole purpose of the individual is not to gain a just response or solution to the situation, but to quench his thirst for revenge. Vengeance can be viewed not only as a negative emotion but also a very destructive one because it blurs the sense of right and wrong of an individual. Justice, however, is very different to vengeance.

Justice can be defined as just behaviour or treatment. Justice is the accepted manner of finding solutions to a problem, by working within a system. For instance, imagine a situation where a criminal is caught by civilians in a small town. If the people hit the criminal and take the law into their hands for the crimes that he has committed against them, then that is vengeance. However, if the people hand him over to the police station so that he can be dealt with in a just manner, then that promotes justice.

In the case of justice, the issue is viewed in an objective manner so that it is fair for both parties. Unlike in the case of vengeance where the individual is driven by his emotions of anger, pain, and hurt, in the case of justice, it is different. The one who committed the crime is given a punishment (by whom? – MD) based on his crime. This creates a just and fair way of settling matters. Unlike vengeance, justice is positive and promotes the well-being of the society.”

* * * *
Having read this far, have you yet begun to pick holes in these definitions? I did. I began to think about my English lessons when I was a schoolboy. My teacher told me that an adjective is ‘a doing word’ or, more formally, any member of a class of words that modify nouns and pronouns, primarily by describing a particular quality of the word they are modifying. As I said: a doing word.

An adverb, on the other hand, any member of a class of words that function as modifiers of verbs or clauses, and in some languages, such as Latin and English, as modifiers of adjectives.

Stay with me. I’ve almost finished. The word ‘racial’ is an adjective. The word ‘racially’ is an adverb. The word ‘Asian’ is both an adjective and a noun. www.dictionary.com confirmed there is no definition for ‘sex gangs’.

An MP is a Member of Parliament who represents, first and foremost, a political party, despite any protestations that, to the contrary, he/she really, truly, honestly, please believe me, represents those who elected him to his post. Apparently these representatives ‘demand’ – from whom?1 – tougher sentences for (anyone found guilty of) ‘grooming’ (an adjective) young (another adjective) white (yet another adjective) girls (noun). Asians versus young white girls. Wow. That’s a humdinger!

In short, the headline is a mish-mash of words designed to attract attention and, presumably, sell the paper. Everything in the headline is modified to achieve a particular effect. It pretends to be concerned with crime but the emphasis is political – hence the combination of reporters who wrote the article.

* * * *

I put it to you that crime, especially adjectivally endorsed crime, is still just crime. No adjectives required. 

From time immemorial all communities across the world – even primitive communities - have maintained order by appointing representatives of that community to hear evidence of crime; and after hearing the evidence, to determine whether the accused is guilty or not guilty as charged; and to determine the just sentence of the community upon the guilty. That includes the community having the power to conclude that a person is guilty or not guilty as charged and at the same time having the power to decide the lightness or severity of the punishment. The head honcho in the community took (should still take) responsibility only for determining that the sentence was applied.

And that describes COMMON LAW and Trial by Jury in action.
 
I contend that rules and statutes which take away and detract from this essential system of self government are driven politically, or else are in pursuit of money and/or power. I’ve discussed elsewhere that the love of money is the root of all evil. It is well said also, that power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. (Attributed to John Emerich Edward Dalberg Acton, first Baron Acton (1834–1902). Later he added: “Great men are almost always bad men."

I conclude that our courts as presently structured are unlawful; that our Parliament as presently structured is unlawful; and that our money-serving news media aids and abets the unlawful processes.
Need I say more? I rest my case. quod erat demonstrandum.

(1)Criminal cases come to court after a decision has been made by, usually the Crown Prosecution Service, to prosecute someone for an alleged crime. In the vast majority of cases (over 95 per cent), magistrates hear the evidence and, as a panel, make a decision on guilt or innocence. For more serious cases a district judge (Magistrates’ Court) or a circuit judge in the Crown Court will hear the evidence, and in the case of the latter, this will involve a jury trial. Very serious criminal cases, such as murder and rape, may be heard by a High Court judge.